Implants vs Dentures: An Honest Comparison From a Dentist Who Offers Both
By Dr. Leily Razavi, DDS, cosmetic and restorative dentist in Center City, Philadelphia. Doctor of Dental Surgery, University of Toronto. General practice residency at Albert Einstein Medical Center.
The short answer
Dentures rest on your gums and come out at night. Implants are anchored in your jawbone and stay in. Dentures cost less at the start and are ready in weeks. Implants cost more at the start, take months to finish, and protect the jawbone a denture lets shrink. There is also a middle option. The details follow.
When a patient is losing teeth, or has already lost them, this is the conversation we eventually have. Implants or dentures. I offer both in my office, and I fit both every month, so I have no reason to push you toward one. What I can do is lay out how they actually differ in daily life, because the differences that matter are not the ones in the brochures.
The real difference is underneath
A denture rests on your gums. It is held by fit, by suction, sometimes by adhesive, and it comes out at night. An implant is anchored in the jawbone, the way a natural root anchors a tooth. The visible part, the tooth you see, is a crown fitted onto that anchor. Everything else in this comparison, how they chew, how they feel, how long they last, how they age, comes back to that one difference. One sits on the gum. The other is part of the jaw.
If several teeth in a row are missing, implants can also hold a fixed bridge. And my page on dental implants in Philadelphia covers the treatment itself in more detail.
The comparison at a glance
|
|
Implants |
Dentures |
Implant-supported denture |
|
How it stays in |
Anchored in the jawbone |
Rests on the gums, held by fit, suction or adhesive |
Clips onto two to four implants |
|
Comes out at night |
No |
Yes |
Yes, for cleaning |
|
Eating |
The closest thing to your own teeth |
A softer, more careful diet |
Far steadier than a denture, close to natural |
|
Your jawbone over time |
Held where the implants sit |
Slowly shrinks |
Held around the implants |
|
Time to finish |
Three to six months |
A few weeks |
In between |
|
Cost pattern |
More up front |
Less up front, keeps costing in relines, repairs and replacements |
In between |
Eating
This is where patients feel the difference first. Teeth anchored in bone chew the way your own teeth chewed. You bite into an apple and nothing moves. A denture chews on the gum, and the gum was never built for that job. Most denture wearers quietly edit their diet over the years. Corn on the cob goes. Steak becomes a negotiation. Sticky food is out. Many people never tell their dentist they made these edits. They just stop ordering certain things.
A well made denture still lets you eat well, and plenty of my patients are happy with theirs. You will eat a softer, more careful version of your diet, and you will think about it in a way implant patients mostly do not.
Talking and daily confidence
A denture that fits well on the day it is delivered can still shift when you laugh, cough, or speak quickly, because the jaw underneath it keeps changing shape (more on that below). Lower dentures are the hardest to keep still, since there is less surface for them to hold onto and your tongue is always in the way. Implants do not move. Patients describe this less as a dental benefit and more as getting their personality back. They stop covering their mouth when they laugh.
The bone question, which is the long-term question
Your jawbone stays where it is because your tooth roots work it every day. Chewing sends pressure through the root, and the bone maintains itself in response. When teeth are lost, that stops. The bone under a denture slowly shrinks, year after year, for as long as you wear it. This is why a denture that fit at delivery needs relining, and why dentures are usually replaced every five to ten years. The denture did not wear out first. The foundation changed under it.
An implant works the bone the way a root did, so the bone around it holds. This is the strongest long-term argument for implants, and it is the one I wish more patients heard before their first denture rather than after their third. It also affects how your face ages, since the jaw is part of what supports it.
Care and maintenance
Dentures come out every night. They get brushed, soaked, and left out while you sleep, and the adhesive, cleaning products and periodic relines and adjustments are part of the routine for as long as you wear them. None of it is difficult. It is simply a daily ritual some people accept and some people come to hate.
Implants are cared for the way natural teeth are cared for. Brush, clean between them, come in for your regular visits. The implant itself cannot decay. The gum around it still needs looking after, and that is part of what we check at your appointments.
Time
A denture is the faster road. From impressions to delivery is usually a matter of weeks. Implants are the slower road. The implant is placed, and then the bone needs three to six months to fuse to it before the final tooth goes on. I wrote a separate article on exactly what that healing looks like, dental implant recovery, week by week, because it is the part patients worry about most and usually the part that goes easier than they feared.
Cost, honestly
Dentures cost less up front. Implants cost more up front. That sentence is true, and it is also incomplete, because the denture keeps costing. Relines, adjustments, repairs, adhesives and cleaning products, and a replacement denture every five to ten years as the jaw changes. The implant’s costs after placement look much like the costs of keeping a natural tooth.
Which one costs less across fifteen years depends on your mouth, and I will not quote generic national numbers at you, because they are not your numbers. What I will do, before any treatment starts, is put both plans in writing with your actual costs for each, so you are comparing real figures for your case. That is how every treatment plan in my office works.
The middle option most people never hear about
There is a third road, and many of my happiest full-arch patients took it. An implant-supported denture clips onto a small number of implants, usually two to four, and comes out at night for cleaning like a regular denture. Because it is anchored, it does not slip when you eat or talk, and it holds bone around the implants. It costs more than a regular denture and less than a full set of fixed implant teeth, and for someone whose denture moves too much, it can change daily life out of proportion to its cost. My page on dentures in Philadelphia covers the regular denture side just as fully. Neither option is the poor relation in my office.
The fixed full arch
At the far end of the implant road is a full set of teeth fixed onto implants, upper, lower, or both. You will see it marketed as All-on-4, after the technique that holds a full arch on four implants. It never comes out at night, and it is the closest thing to starting over with your own teeth. It is also the largest treatment plan I put together, and my page on full mouth reconstruction covers what a rebuild of that size involves.
Who each one suits
Dentures tend to suit people who want no surgery, who need teeth quickly, whose budget has to stay lower this year, or whose health makes surgery a poor idea. Implants tend to suit people who have the bone, or can build it with bone grafting, who want to stop thinking about their teeth, and who are planning for the longest horizon. The snap-in denture suits people in the middle, most often people who already wear a denture and are tired of it moving.
There is no version of this decision I would make from an article, including mine. Your bone, your health, your remaining teeth and your budget are all in the room when we decide, and they should be.
How we decide in my office
We look first. I examine your mouth and your bone, and then we talk about what you want the next fifteen years of eating and smiling to feel like. I will tell you which option I would choose with your mouth and your circumstances, and I will tell you why. Then you decide, with the full costs of each plan in front of you, in writing, before anything begins.
Questions patients ask me about implants and dentures
Which is better, implants or dentures?
Neither wins for everyone. Implants are anchored in bone, chew like natural teeth, and protect the jaw. Dentures cost less at the start, need no surgery, and are finished in weeks. The right answer depends on your bone, your health, your budget and how you want to live with the result. My job is to show you both honestly and let your situation decide.
Do dentures hurt?
A new denture has an adjustment period, and sore spots in the first weeks are common while we adjust the fit. What surprises people more is the long term. As the jaw shrinks under the denture, the fit loosens, and a loose denture rubs. Relines fix that for a while. If your denture hurts or moves, that is a fit problem to bring to me, not something you have to live with.
How long do implants and dentures last?
An implant is built to last decades, and the crown on it is a working tooth surface that can eventually need replacement the way a crown on a natural tooth does. A denture is usually replaced every five to ten years, because the jaw it sits on keeps changing shape. That replacement rhythm is the main reason the long-term cost gap between the two is smaller than the first price suggests.
Can I switch from dentures to implants later?
Yes, and many patients do. The one caution is bone. The longer a denture is worn, the more the jaw underneath it shrinks, and implants need bone to anchor in. Sometimes grafting can rebuild what was lost. If you think implants might be in your future, it is worth having the conversation early, while you have the most bone to work with.
What if I only need to replace some of my teeth?
Then we are talking about partial solutions, and both families have them. A partial denture replaces several teeth and comes out at night. Implants can replace individual teeth or hold a fixed bridge across a gap, leaving your healthy teeth untouched. Which one makes sense depends on which teeth are missing and what shape the neighbors are in, and it is exactly the kind of thing we map out together at a first visit.
If you are choosing between implants and dentures,
. We will look at your mouth, talk through both plans with your real costs in writing, and you will decide with everything in front of you. Call us at (215) 996-7030 to schedule a consult.
Dr. Leily Razavi
EXCELLENT Based on 191 reviews Posted on Jessica StelmaTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Beautiful office with friendly staff and a very thoughtful consult by Dr. Razavi. I'm excited to put her action plan in place.Posted on Anne RyanTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Amazing experience . Very professional and kind staff.Posted on Thomas CaldwellTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I had an excellent experience at Razavi Dental. The service was top-notch, with the staff being very friendly and professional. The office was clean and well-organized, which made the whole visit comfortable. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for quality dental care.Posted on E YTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Dr Razavi is the best dentist I’ve ever had. I’ve seen Dr Razavi over the years for regular dental care as well as cosmetic dentistry …her work is impeccable, a combination of technical expertise and artistry. The practice has a welcoming and supportive staff, fastidious hygienist and is immaculate and state of the art. Obviously I can’t say enough good things about Dr Razavi and Razavi Dental.Posted on Margaret RockeyTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Dr. Razavi is an artist and her staff are stars. Thorough, kind, professional, and just fun people to be around. I’ve had both regular cleanings and cosmetic work done here and it’s all top notch. You don’t usually think of going to the dentist as a pleasure but with them it is. Also their office is beautiful and they have what I swear is dental equipment from the future!Posted on Megan ParkerTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Beautiful, clean office. Friendly, knowledgeable staff.Posted on Julie LTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Best dentist in town